The Power Pair: Australian Shiraz vs. French Rhône Syrah
When it comes to bold, complex reds, few varietals command as much respect as Syrah—or as it’s more commonly known in Australia, Shiraz. Though genetically the same grape, these two expressions hail from different hemispheres and tell two distinct stories in the glass. From the sun-drenched vineyards of the Barossa to the steep granite slopes of the Northern Rhône, this is a tale of terroir, tradition, and transformation.
One Grape, Two Identities
Syrah originated in France’s Rhône Valley, where it thrives in both the cooler north and the warmer southern appellations. In Australia, particularly in South Australia’s Barossa and McLaren Vale regions, the grape was renamed Shiraz and took on a new personality—bolder, fruitier, and unmistakably Aussie.
Despite being the same grape, Syrah and Shiraz express themselves differently, influenced by climate, soil, and winemaking philosophy. Let’s break it down:
French Rhône Style Syrah: Elegant, Earthy, and Age-Worthy
In Northern Rhône appellations like Hermitage, Côte-Rôtie, and Cornas, Syrah is often the sole grape used. These wines tend to be restrained, aromatic, and structured, often showing notes of:
-
Black olive
-
Crushed pepper
-
Leather
-
Violet
-
Smoke and earthy minerality
They’re typically medium-bodied with high acidity and fine tannins, making them excellent candidates for long-term aging. In the Southern Rhône, Syrah plays a supporting role in blends like Châteauneuf-du-Pape, adding spice and structure to Grenache-dominant wines.
Notable Producer Examples:
-
Jean-Luc Colombo
-
E. Guigal
-
Domaine Jamet
Australian Shiraz: Bold, Lush, and Generous
Across the seas in Australia, Shiraz evolved into a much richer, more full-bodied expression. Thanks to the warmer climate and innovative winemaking, Aussie Shiraz often bursts with:
-
Ripe blackberry
-
Plum
-
Dark chocolate
-
Sweet spice (clove, anise)
-
Toasty oak
Barossa Valley Shiraz is particularly famous for its power and intensity, while Cool-Climate Shiraz from regions like the Yarra Valley or Canberra District show a lighter, peppery style that nods back to the Rhône.
Top Aussie Shiraz Producers:
-
Rockford
-
Kaesler
-
Yarra Yering
-
Henschke
-
Clonakilla (for cool-climate Shiraz-Viognier blends)
Food Pairing Showdown
|
French Syrah
|
Australian Shiraz
|
|---|---|
|
Lamb chops with rosemary
|
Smoky BBQ ribs or grilled steak
|
|
Duck breast with black olive tapenade
|
Aged cheddar or blue cheese
|
|
Wild mushroom risotto
|
Pepper-crusted kangaroo or venison
|
Each style complements a different culinary mood. Rhône Syrah elevates subtle, earthy flavors, while Australian Shiraz thrives alongside rich, hearty dishes.
Which Should You Choose?
-
For elegance, spice, and tradition? Go Rhône.
-
For boldness, fruit, and crowd-pleasing richness? Go Aussie.
Or better yet—drink both and compare. Hosting a Syrah vs. Shiraz tasting is a fantastic way to experience how one grape can showcase two completely different worlds of wine.
Final Sip
Whether you lean French or Australian, Syrah/Shiraz remains one of the most versatile and expressive red wine grapes on the planet. Its ability to adapt to its environment—and reflect it so clearly in the glass—is a testament to the power of terroir.
So next time you're browsing the shelves or curating your next dinner party pour, remember: The power is in the pair.
WINES:
Australian Shiraz Selections
-
Rockford Basket Press Shiraz 2021 A quintessential Barossa Valley Shiraz, this wine offers intense aromas of dark berries, black pepper, and hints of vanilla. The palate is full-bodied with flavors of ripe blackberries, plums, and a touch of spice, culminating in a long, lingering finish.
-
Clarendon Hills Piggott Range Syrah Hailing from McLaren Vale, this Syrah presents intense aromas of blackberry, plum, and dark chocolate, with hints of black pepper and smoked meat. The palate is rich and full-bodied, featuring flavors of ripe black fruits, espresso, and a touch of vanilla, leading to a long and satisfying finish.
-
Hungerford Hill Epic Shiraz 2022 This premium Shiraz showcases a deep ruby color with vibrant purple hues. Expect an enticing bouquet of dark berries, plum, and hints of black pepper, complemented by subtle oak and vanilla undertones. The palate is full-bodied and rich, featuring flavors of ripe blackberry, dark chocolate, and a touch of spice.
French Rhône Syrah-Inspired Australian Wines
-
Domaine De Dionysos Côtes du Rhône
A vibrant and approachable Rhône red showing juicy red berries, cracked pepper, and subtle earthy notes—a classic expression of southern Syrah-led blends. -
Domaine Les Genestas Signargues Côtes du Rhône Villages 2023
From one of the Rhône’s top village appellations, this wine delivers bold blackberry fruit, Provençal herbs, and a touch of garrigue-driven complexity. -
Guigal Côtes du Rhône Rouge 2020
A benchmark Rhône blend by one of the region’s most respected producers, offering dark fruit, spice, and refined structure with remarkable consistency and value.
